Classification and Types of Surveys

TL;DR

Surveys in land measurement are categorized based on their purpose, the instruments used, and the methods applied, each suited for different scales and precision requirements. Geodetic surveys account for the Earth's curvature for large areas, while plane surveys treat the Earth as flat for smaller areas. Understanding these classifications helps you choose the right approach for any given project.

1. The Mental Model

Imagine you need to measure a piece of land. Would you use the same tools and methods for measuring your backyard as you would for mapping an entire country? Probably not! Different survey types are like different toolkits, each designed for a specific job, scale, and level of accuracy.

2. The Core Material

Surveying is all about determining the relative positions of points on, above, or below the Earth's surface. To do this effectively, we classify surveys based on several factors. This helps in selecting the appropriate techniques, instruments, and personnel.

2.1 Primary Classification: Earth's Curvature

Photo by Zelch Csaba on Pexels

The most fundamental way to classify surveys is by whether they account for the Earth's curvature.

Plane Surveying

• Concept: In plane surveying, you assume the Earth's surface within the survey area is a flat plane. You disregard the spherical shape of the Earth.
• When to use: This is suitable for small areas (typically less than 250 km² or 100 square miles). The errors introduced by neglecting curvature are negligible for these scales.
• Examples: Property boundary surveys, construction site layouts, small topographical maps.
• Tools: The calculations are based on plane trigonometry and geometry.

Geodetic Surveying

• Concept: In geodetic surveying, you explicitly consider the Earth's true shape (an oblate spheroid). All measurements are reduced to a reference ellipsoid or geoid.
• When to use: Essential for large areas, national mapping, establishing control points, and any survey requiring high precision over long distances.
• Examples: Establishing national control networks, mapping continents, large-scale engineering projects like dams or tunnels that span significant distances.
• Tools: Involves spherical trigonometry and advanced mathematical models of the Earth's shape.

Here's a simple comparison:

graph TD
    A["Survey Classification"] --> B["Consider Earth's Curvature?"];
    B --> C{{"No (Small Area)"}};
    B --> D{{"Yes (Large Area)"}};
    C --> E["Plane Surveying"];
    D --> F["Geodetic Surveying"];
    E --> G["Flat Earth Assumption"];
    E --> H["Plane Geometry/Trigonometry"];
    F --> I["Earth's True Shape (Ellipsoid/Geoid)"];
    F --> J["Spherical Geometry/Trigonometry"];
    G & H --> K["Local property lines, building layouts"];
    I & J --> L["National mapping, continent-scale projects"];

2.2 Classification by Purpose

Photo by https://kaboompics.com/ on Pexels

Surveys are also classified by why they are being conducted.

• Topographical Surveys: Determine the natural and artificial features of an area, including elevation changes. The goal is to produce contour maps or digital elevation models.
• Cadastral Surveys: Focus on establishing or re-establishing property boundaries. These are legal surveys crucial for land ownership and taxation.
• Engineering Surveys: Provide data for the design and construction of engineering projects (roads, bridges, buildings, pipelines). They include preliminary surveys (site selection), design surveys (detailed layout), and construction surveys (staking out features).
• Construction Surveys: A subset of engineering surveys, specifically for guiding construction work, ensuring structures are built according to design.
• Route Surveys: Specifically for linear projects like roads, railways, pipelines, and transmission lines, determining the best path and elevations.
• Mining Surveys: Used in both surface and underground mining operations to control excavation, map geological features, and ensure safety.
• Hydrographic Surveys: Map coastlines, lakes, rivers, and oceans, focusing on water depths, underwater topography, and features relevant for navigation, dredging, or offshore construction.
• Astronomical Surveys: Determine the absolute positions of points on the Earth's surface by observing celestial bodies. Used for precise geodetic control.
• Photogrammetric Surveys: Use photographs (taken from aircraft or drones) to create maps and models.
• Geological Surveys: Used to determine geological formations and strata below the Earth's surface, often in conjunction with mining or engineering projects.

2.3 Classification by Instrument Used

Photo by Elizabeth Tamara on Pexels

The specific tools employed also help categorize surveys.

• Chain/Tape Surveys: Uses chains or tapes for linear measurements. Mostly historical for primary measurements, but still used for short distances or checking.
• Compass Surveys: Uses a magnetic compass for angular measurements (bearings), and chains/tapes for distances. Good for preliminary reconnaissance or less precise work.
• Theodolite/Total Station Surveys: Employs a theodolite (for angles) or a total station (for angles and distances) for highly accurate measurements. This is a very common method today.
• GPS (Global Positioning System) Surveys: Uses satellite signals to determine precise positions. Excellent for establishing control networks and capturing large amounts of data quickly.
• Leveling Surveys: Specifically uses a level and staff to determine relative heights (elevations) of points.

2.4 Classification by Method Employed

Photo by Kathleen Newman on Pexels

• Triangulation: Creating a network of triangles, measuring all angles and at least one side (baseline), then calculating other sides using trigonometry.
• Traversing: Moving from one known point to the next, measuring angles and distances between successive points to establish their positions. Can be closed (starting and ending at the same or known point) or open.
• Trilateration: Similar to triangulation, but measuring all sides of the triangles and calculating angles. Often used with electronic distance measurement (EDM) instruments.

3. Worked Example

Let's say you need to lay out a new residential subdivision with 50 homes, covering an area of approximately 1 square kilometer. You also need to establish the exact boundaries for each lot and design the roads and utilities.

1. Primary Classification: Given the area (1 km² is much less than 250 km²), you'd use Plane Surveying. The Earth's curvature won't significantly affect your measurements at this scale.
2. Purpose Classification:
   • You'll need a Topographical Survey first to understand the existing terrain (hills, valleys, streams) for road design and drainage.
   • Then, a Cadastral Survey is essential to define the property lines of the new lots, tie them to existing legal boundaries, and ensure clear ownership.
   • Engineering Surveys will follow for the detailed design and layout of roads, water lines, sewer systems, and other infrastructure.
3. Instrument Classification:
   • For establishing overall control points and gathering topographic data efficiently, GPS Surveys would be very useful.
   • For precise layout of road centerlines, building corners, and utility locations, Total Station Surveys are ideal.
   • Leveling Surveys would be critical for establishing precise grades for roads, drainage, and utility trenches.
4. Method Employed:
   • You'd likely use Traversing to establish control points around and within the subdivision, providing a framework for all other measurements.

4. Key Takeaways

• Surveys are classified primarily by whether they account for the Earth's curvature (Plane vs. Geodetic).
• Plane surveys assume a flat Earth and are for smaller areas; geodetic surveys consider curvature for larger, high-precision projects.
• The purpose of the survey (e.g., topographical, cadastral, engineering) dictates the type of information you collect.
• The instruments used (e.g., total station, GPS, level) depend on the required accuracy, scale, and budget.
• Common methods like traversing and triangulation are techniques for establishing point positions.
• Combining different classifications helps you choose the most efficient and accurate approach for a project.
• Mistake 1: Using plane surveying for a very large area, leading to significant errors in calculations.
• Mistake 2: Not clearly defining the purpose of the survey before starting, resulting in collecting irrelevant data or missing crucial information.
• Mistake 3: Choosing instruments that are either overkill (too expensive/slow) or insufficient for the required precision.
• Mistake 4: Confusing survey types (e.g., thinking a topographic survey automatically provides legal boundaries).

5. Now Try It

Imagine you're tasked with planning a survey for a new 100-kilometer high-speed rail line connecting two major cities. Describe which primary survey type (Plane or Geodetic) you'd use and why. Then, identify at least three specific "purpose" classifications of surveys that would be involved throughout the project lifecycle (from planning to construction) and briefly explain why each is necessary.

Success looks like: You correctly identify Geodetic surveying and explain its necessity due to the distance. You also list three relevant purpose-based survey types (e.g., Route, Topographical, Engineering, Cadastral, Hydrographic if crossing water) with a clear, concise reason for each.