Types and Scope of Public Policy

TL;DR

Public policies are essentially what governments choose to do or not do about public issues, and they come in different forms depending on their goals and how they affect people. Understanding these types helps you see how policies aim to solve problems and where they fit within a government's broader actions. Their scope can range from very specific issues affecting a small group to broad societal changes.

1. The Mental Model

Think of public policies as the government's playbook for running society. Just like a sports team has different plays for offense, defense, or special situations, governments have different types of policies (the plays) to tackle various public challenges (the situations) with different goals.

2. The Core Material

Public policies are a course of action (or inaction) taken by governmental actors to address a specific issue. They are not just laws; they include regulations, funding decisions, programs, and even the choices governments make not to intervene.

Types of Public Policies

Photo by Markus Winkler on Pexels

Different scholars categorize policies in various ways, but a common and useful framework looks at their impact and purpose:

• Distributive Policies: These policies allocate resources or services to specific segments of the population. They often involve direct benefits, subsidies, or services. Think of them as spreading things out.

  • Example: Funding for highway construction, agricultural subsidies, public education. These benefits are often seen as "everyone's right" and don't typically involve direct competition for resources.

• Redistributive Policies: These policies aim to shift resources, income, or wealth from one group to another, often from the wealthy to the less wealthy. They explicitly seek to alter the existing distribution of resources.

  • Example: Progressive income tax (higher earners pay a higher percentage), welfare programs, Medicaid, social security. These often generate more debate because they involve taking from one group to give to another.

• Regulatory Policies: These policies impose restrictions or controls on the behavior of individuals or groups to protect the public good. They aim to limit or control actions.

  • Example: Environmental protection laws (e.g., limits on pollution), food safety standards, zoning ordinances, speed limits. These dictate what you can and can't do.

• Constituent Policies: These policies deal with the structure, organization, and procedures of government itself. They are about how the government operates.

  • Example: Creation of new government agencies, electoral reforms, appointments of judges, changes to legislative procedures. These aren't about direct public benefits but about the machinery of government.

Scope of Public Policy

Photo by Rahul Sapra on Pexels

The scope of a policy refers to how broad or narrow its impact is, how many people it affects, and the level of government at which it's enacted.

• Narrow Scope: Policies that address a very specific issue affecting a small group or a particular industry.

  • Example: A local ordinance banning plastic bags in one town, specific tax breaks for a single industry, or funding for a rare disease research program.

• Broad Scope: Policies that affect large populations, multiple sectors, or have widespread societal implications. These often involve significant resources and coordination.

  • Example: National healthcare reform, climate change legislation, universal education policies, or national economic stimulus packages.

Understanding the interplay between policy types and their scope helps explain why some policies are easier to pass than others, why some generate more conflict, and who benefits or loses from particular government actions.

Here's how these types often relate to each other:

graph TD
    A["Public Policy Goals"] --> B{"Policy Type?"}

    B -- "Distribute benefits/resources?" --> C["Distributive Policy"]
    C --> C1["(e.g., Infrastructure, Education Funding)"]

    B -- "Shift wealth/income?" --> D["Redistributive Policy"]
    D --> D1["(e.g., Progressive Tax, Welfare)"]

    B -- "Control behavior/actions?" --> E["Regulatory Policy"]
    E --> E1["(e.g., Environmental Laws, Safety Standards)"]

    B -- "Structure/manage government?" --> F["Constituent Policy"]
    F --> F1["(e.g., Agency Creation, Electoral Reform)"]

3. Worked Example

Let's consider the Affordable Care Act (ACA) in the United States as an example.

• Redistributive: A core aim of the ACA was to expand health insurance coverage, which involved creating mechanisms to subsidize coverage for lower-income individuals and families (e.g., through tax credits). This effectively shifted financial burdens and benefits.
• Regulatory: The ACA also imposed significant regulations on insurance companies (e.g., prohibiting denial of coverage for pre-existing conditions, requiring certain essential health benefits) and individuals (e.g., the individual mandate to purchase insurance, though this was later repealed).
• Distributive: While less central than redistribution, aspects like grants for community health centers could be seen as distributive, allocating resources to specific health service providers.
• Scope: The ACA was a broad-scope policy, affecting virtually all Americans, insurance markets, healthcare providers, and state governments across the nation. It was a massive undertaking with widespread implications.

You can see how one major policy often contains elements of multiple types to achieve its overarching goals.

4. Key Takeaways

• Public policies are government actions (or inactions) designed to address public problems.
• Distributive policies allocate resources or services widely, like funding for roads or schools.
• Redistributive policies aim to shift wealth or resources from one group to another, often from rich to poor.
• Regulatory policies set rules and restrictions to control behavior for the public good, such as environmental laws.
• Constituent policies define how the government itself is structured and operates.
• The scope of a policy describes how broad or narrow its impact is, from specific local issues to national, systemic changes.

Common mistakes to avoid:
- Don't confuse a program with a policy; a program is an implementation of a policy.
- Don't assume all policies are about money; many are about rules and organization.
- Don't think a policy fits neatly into only one category; many combine elements of different types.
- Don't overlook the impact of inaction as a policy choice; not addressing an issue is still a policy.

5. Now Try It

Choose a recent health policy decision or debate in your country (e.g., changes to prescription drug pricing, a new public health campaign, a hospital closure). Identify which of the policy types (distributive, redistributive, regulatory, constituent) are most prominent in this policy, and explain why. Then, describe whether its scope is narrow or broad, providing specific reasons.

What success looks like: You should be able to clearly identify at least two policy types involved and provide a concise justification for each, alongside a clear assessment of its scope.