Introduction to Obedience and Social Psychology

TL;DR

Obedience is when you change your behavior due to a direct order from an authority figure. Social psychology explores how your thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are influenced by others. Understanding obedience helps us see how powerful social situations can be.

1. The Mental Model

Imagine you're told to do something by someone in charge. You might question it, but often, you'll go along with it. This isn't just about being weak; it's about powerful psychological processes at play.

2. The Core Material

What is Obedience?

Photo by Sam Lion on Pexels

Obedience is a form of social influence where an individual acts in response to a direct order from another individual, who is usually an authority figure. It's different from conformity, where you adjust your behavior to fit in with a group. With obedience, there's an explicit command.

Key Studies in Obedience

Photo by Brett Jordan on Pexels

The most famous study on obedience is Stanley Milgram's experiment. He wanted to understand why people would follow orders that involved harming others, particularly in the context of the Holocaust.

Milgram's Experiment (1963):
* Participants: Recruited ordinary men from the community.
* Roles: Participants were always the "teacher," and a confederate (actor) was the "learner." An experimenter (authority figure) wore a lab coat.
* Task: The teacher was instructed to deliver electric shocks of increasing intensity to the learner for incorrect answers. The shocks were fake, but the teacher believed they were real.
* Learner's Reactions: The confederate would grunt, complain, and eventually fall silent as shock levels increased.
* Experimenter's Prods: If the teacher hesitated, the experimenter would use prods like "Please continue" or "The experiment requires that you continue."

Results: A staggering 65% of participants delivered the maximum 450-volt shock, even when the learner appeared to be in distress or unresponsive. This showed that ordinary people are surprisingly willing to obey authority, even when it conflicts with their conscience.

Why Do People Obey? (Factors Affecting Obedience)

Photo by Mercy Protas on Pexels

Several factors can increase or decrease obedience:

• Proximity of the Authority Figure: The closer the authority figure, the higher the obedience.
• Legitimacy of the Authority Figure: If the authority figure seems legitimate (e.g., wearing a uniform, in a respectable setting), obedience increases.
• Proximity of the Victim: The closer the victim, the lower the obedience. It's harder to harm someone you can see or hear.
• Group Pressure/Social Support: If others defy the authority, obedience decreases significantly.
• Personal Responsibility: When people feel they are just following orders and not personally responsible, obedience increases (agentic state).

graph TD
    A["Authority Figure Present?"] -->|Yes| B["Legitimate Authority?"]
    A -->|No| C["Less Obedience"]

    B -->|Yes| D["Victim Proximity?"]
    B -->|No| C

    D -->|Close| E["Less Obedience"]
    D -->|Distant| F["Others Obeying?"]

    F -->|Yes| G["Increased Obedience (Agentic State)"]
    F -->|No| E

What is Social Psychology?

Photo by MART PRODUCTION on Pexels

Social psychology is the scientific study of how individuals' thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are influenced by the actual, imagined, or implied presence of others. It looks at how social situations impact us. Obedience is a key topic within social psychology, alongside conformity, altruism, prejudice, and group dynamics.

3. Worked Example

Imagine you're walking in a park, and someone in a bright, official-looking vest tells you to move to a different path because of "construction ahead." Even if you don't see any construction, you're likely to obey. This is an example of obedience because:

1. Direct Order: The person gave you a clear command ("move to a different path").
2. Authority Figure: The official-looking vest suggests they have some authority, even if you don't know who they are specifically.
3. Influence on Behavior: Your action of moving is directly influenced by their order.

If, instead, you saw a group of people walking on a different path and decided to follow them without anyone telling you to, that would be conformity, not obedience.

4. Key Takeaways

• Obedience is following direct orders from an authority figure.
• Milgram's experiment showed that ordinary people can obey harmful commands under specific circumstances.
• Factors like authority's legitimacy and proximity, and victim's proximity, strongly influence obedience.
• The "agentic state" explains how people shift responsibility to the authority, increasing obedience.

• Social psychology studies how social situations affect individual thoughts, feelings, and actions.

• Common Mistakes to Avoid:

  • Confusing obedience with conformity; obedience is a direct command, conformity is group influence without a direct order.
  • Assuming Milgram's results mean people are inherently evil; it highlights the power of social situations.
  • Forgetting that proximity of the victim decreases obedience, while proximity of the authority increases it.
  • Not understanding that legitimacy of the authority figure is crucial for high obedience.

5. Now Try It

Think about a time you've obeyed an instruction from someone. Briefly describe the situation and explain how at least two of the factors (e.g., proximity of authority, legitimacy of authority, proximity of victim, social support, personal responsibility) might have influenced your obedience or disobedience.

Success looks like: Clearly identifying the direct order and authority figure, and linking your behavior to two specific factors discussed above.