Theory of Production and Cost in the Short Run

TL;DR

In the short run, at least one factor of production is fixed, which impacts how output changes with more variable inputs. This leads to crucial concepts like diminishing returns and various cost curves that shape a firm's decisions. Understanding these relationships is key to seeing how firms optimize production and costs.

1. The Mental Model

Imagine you own a small bakery. You can hire more bakers (variable input) or buy more ingredients, but you can't quickly expand your oven space or the size of your shop (fixed inputs). This short-run constraint is what we're looking at.

2. The Core Material

When we talk about the short run in economics, it's a period where at least one factor of production is fixed (e.g., factory size, machinery), while others are variable (e.g., labour, raw materials). This distinction is critical because it directly affects how a firm can increase its output and, consequently, its costs.

Production Concepts

Photo by Markus Winkler on Pexels

• Total Product (TP): This is the total output produced by a firm using a given amount of inputs. As you add more variable inputs (like workers), TP usually increases, but not always at the same rate.
• Average Product (AP): This tells you the output per unit of the variable input. You calculate it as TP divided by the quantity of the variable input (e.g., TP / number of workers). It's a measure of efficiency.
• Marginal Product (MP): This is the additional output gained from employing one more unit of the variable input. You calculate it as the change in TP divided by the change in the variable input. MP is crucial for understanding diminishing returns.

Law of Diminishing Marginal Returns

This is a fundamental concept. It states that as you add successive units of a variable input to a fixed input, eventually the marginal product of the variable input will start to decline. Think back to the bakery: adding a few bakers to one oven increases output significantly. But add too many, and they start getting in each other's way, making each additional baker contribute less to total output.

graph TD
    A["Increase Variable Input (e.g., Workers)"] --> B{"Initially: MP of Variable Input Rises"};
    B --> C["TP Increases at an Increasing Rate"];
    C --> D{"Then: MP of Variable Input Starts to Fall (Diminishing Returns)"};
    D --> E["TP Increases at a Decreasing Rate"];
    E --> F{"Eventually: MP of Variable Input Becomes Zero or Negative"};
    F --> G["TP Reaches Maximum or Starts to Fall"];

Cost Concepts

Photo by Kindel Media on Pexels

Costs are categorised based on their relationship to output and the fixed/variable nature of inputs.

• Total Fixed Cost (TFC): These costs don't change with the level of output. You have to pay them even if you produce nothing (e.g., rent, insurance, depreciation on machinery).
• Total Variable Cost (TVC): These costs change directly with the level of output. The more you produce, the higher your TVC (e.g., raw materials, wages for production workers).
• Total Cost (TC): Simply the sum of TFC and TVC (TC = TFC + TVC).

Average Costs

These show you the cost per unit of output.

• Average Fixed Cost (AFC): TFC divided by the quantity of output (AFC = TFC / Q). AFC always falls as output increases because you're spreading the fixed cost over more units.
• Average Variable Cost (AVC): TVC divided by the quantity of output (AVC = TVC / Q). AVC typically falls initially due to increasing returns, then rises due to diminishing returns.
• Average Total Cost (ATC): TC divided by the quantity of output (ATC = TC / Q), or AFC + AVC. It's usually U-shaped because of the combined effect of falling AFC and rising AVC.

Marginal Cost (MC)

This is the additional cost incurred from producing one more unit of output. It's calculated as the change in TC divided by the change in output (MC = ΔTC / ΔQ). Critically, MC is driven by the marginal product of variable inputs. When MP is rising, MC is falling. When MP is falling (diminishing returns), MC is rising. This is why the MC curve is typically U-shaped and intersects both AVC and ATC at their lowest points.

The relationship between MC, AVC, and ATC is important:
* When MC is below AVC (or ATC), it pulls AVC (or ATC) down.
* When MC is above AVC (or ATC), it pulls AVC (or ATC) up.
* Therefore, MC must intersect AVC and ATC at their minimum points.

3. Worked Example

Let's use our bakery. Suppose the fixed cost (rent for the shop) is $100. We can vary the number of bakers and their wages are $50 per baker.

Notice:
* MP initially rises (from 10 to 15) then falls (diminishing returns start after the 2nd baker).
* MC mirrors this: falls when MP rises, then rises sharply when MP falls.
* AFC continuously declines.
* AVC and ATC are U-shaped. MC intersects AVC and ATC at their lowest points (or close to it in this discrete example).

4. Key Takeaways

• The short run means at least one input is fixed, limiting how quickly a firm can adjust production capacity.
• The Law of Diminishing Marginal Returns states that adding more of a variable input to a fixed input will eventually cause its marginal product to fall.
• Total Fixed Costs (TFC) don't change with output, while Total Variable Costs (TVC) do.
• Average Fixed Cost (AFC) always decreases as output increases.
• Marginal Cost (MC) represents the additional cost of producing one more unit and is directly linked to the marginal product of variable inputs.
• The U-shape of Average Variable Cost (AVC) and Average Total Cost (ATC) curves is due to the interplay of increasing and then diminishing returns.

Common mistakes to avoid:
- Confusing the short run with a specific calendar period; it's defined by fixed inputs, not days or months.
- Forgetting that TFC exists even at zero output, impacting TC and ATC.
- Not understanding why MC intersects AVC and ATC at their minimums – it's a mathematical necessity, not a coincidence.
- Mixing up average product (output per unit of input) with average cost (cost per unit of output).

5. Now Try It

Using the same bakery example, imagine the fixed cost (rent) increases to