Audit Evidence and Internal Controls
From the AA curriculum
TL;DR
Auditors gather sufficient, appropriate audit evidence to form an opinion on financial statements. This evidence is obtained through various procedures, with its quality judged by relevance and reliability. Internal controls are crucial systems implemented by a company to prevent and detect misstatements, which auditors evaluate to determine their reliance.
1. The Mental Model
Think of auditing like being a detective. You're trying to figure out if a story (the financial statements) is true. To do this, you need clues (audit evidence), and you also need to understand how the company tries to ensure its own story is accurate (internal controls).
2. The Core Material
Audit Evidence (ISA 500)

Photo by Pixabay on Pexels
Audit evidence is all the information auditors use to draw conclusions on which to base their audit opinion. It needs to be sufficient (enough of it) and appropriate (relevant and reliable).
Assertions
Financial statements aren't just numbers; they contain implicit "assertions" or claims made by management. Auditors test these claims.
Here are the main assertions you'll encounter, split by type:
-
Classes of Transactions and Events (and related disclosures) for the period under audit:
- Occurrence: Did recorded transactions actually happen?
- Completeness: Have all transactions that should have been recorded been recorded?
- Accuracy: Were transactions recorded at the correct amounts?
- Cut-off: Were transactions recorded in the correct accounting period?
- Classification: Were transactions recorded in the proper accounts?
- Presentation: Are transactions appropriately aggregated, disaggregated, and clearly described?
-
Account Balances (and related disclosures) at the period end:
- Existence: Do assets, liabilities, and equity interests actually exist?
- Rights and Obligations: Does the entity hold or control the rights to assets, and are liabilities obligations of the entity?
- Completeness: Have all assets, liabilities, and equity interests that should have been recorded been recorded?
- Valuation and Allocation: Are assets, liabilities, and equity interests included in the financial statements at appropriate amounts and are any valuation adjustments properly recorded?
- Presentation: Are assets, liabilities, and equity interests appropriately aggregated, disaggregated, and clearly described?
Audit Procedures to Obtain Evidence
These are the specific actions auditors perform to gather evidence:
- Inspection: Examining records or documents (internal/external, paper/electronic) or physically examining an asset.
- Example: Checking a purchase invoice to verify a trade payable.
- Observation: Looking at a process or procedure being performed by others.
- Example: Observing inventory counting procedures.
- External Confirmation: Obtaining a direct written response to the auditor from a third party.
- Example: Sending confirmation letters to customers to verify trade receivables balances.
- Recalculation: Checking the mathematical accuracy of documents or records.
- Example: Recalculating depreciation expenses.
- Re-performance: Independent execution by the auditor of procedures or controls that were originally performed by the entity’s internal control.
- Example: Re-performing a bank reconciliation.
- Analytical Procedures: Evaluations of financial information through analysis of plausible relationships among both financial and non-financial data.
- Example: Comparing current year revenue to prior year revenue and investigating significant fluctuations.
- Enquiry: Seeking information from knowledgeable persons, both financial and non-financial, within the entity or outside the entity.
- Example: Asking management about inventory obsolescence.
Quality and Quantity of Audit Evidence
- Sufficiency: Refers to the quantity of audit evidence. More risk usually means more evidence needed.
- Appropriateness: Refers to the quality of audit evidence, which is determined by its relevance and reliability.
- Relevance: Does the evidence relate to the assertion being tested?
- Reliability: Is the evidence trustworthy? Generally, evidence is more reliable if it's:
- Obtained from independent external sources.
- Generated internally with effective internal controls.
- Obtained directly by the auditor.
- In documentary form.
- Original documents rather than copies.
Substantive Procedures vs. Tests of Controls
- Tests of Controls: Procedures designed to evaluate the operating effectiveness of controls in preventing or detecting material misstatements at the assertion level.
- Example: Observing an employee performing a bank reconciliation and signing off on it.
- Substantive Procedures: Procedures designed to detect material misstatements at the assertion level. These include tests of details (transactions, balances, disclosures) and substantive analytical procedures.
- Example: Confirming trade receivables balances with customers (test of details) or comparing sales trends with industry data (substantive analytical procedure).
Internal Controls

Photo by Reiner Schneider on Pexels
Internal controls are processes implemented by an entity's management to provide reasonable assurance about achieving objectives related to financial reporting reliability, operational effectiveness, and compliance with laws.
Components of Internal Control
Generally, internal controls consist of five interrelated components:
1. Control Environment: The overall tone at the top, management's philosophy, integrity, ethical values.
2. Entity's Risk Assessment Process: How management identifies, assesses, and responds to business risks.
3. Information System: The system relevant to financial reporting, including accounting and business processes.
4. Control Activities: The policies and procedures that help ensure management directives are carried out (e.g., authorisations, reconciliations, segregation of duties).
5. Monitoring of Controls: Processes to assess the effectiveness of internal control performance over time.
Limitations of Internal Controls
Even strong internal controls have limitations:
* Human error: Mistakes can happen.
* Collusion: Two or more people can override controls.
* Management override: Management can intentionally bypass controls.
* Cost vs. Benefit: Controls shouldn't cost more than the benefit they provide.
* Unusual transactions: Controls might not be designed for unique, one-off events.
Internal Audit Function
The internal audit function is an independent, objective assurance and consulting activity designed to add value and improve an
Frequently asked about Audit Evidence and Internal Controls
Study this next
Get the full AA curriculum
Clone the complete plan to your dashboard for unlimited AI-generated notes, practice quizzes, and a personalised revision schedule.
Save this course free