Information Services and User Studies

TL;DR

Information services are all about connecting users with the right information, resources, and support. User studies are how we understand what users actually need and how they behave. By studying users, we can design and improve services that are truly useful and effective.

1. The Mental Model

Think of it like being a chef: you can't just cook what you like. You need to understand your customers' tastes, dietary needs, and how they eat to create dishes they'll truly enjoy and find satisfying. In library and information science, users are your customers, and information services are your dishes.

2. The Core Material

Information services encompass all the ways libraries and information centers help people find, use, and understand information. These aren't just about handing over a book; they're about providing guidance, access, and sometimes even creating new information products.

Types of Information Services

Photo by Kampus Production on Pexels

You'll encounter many types of services, but they generally fall into a few categories:

• Reference Services: This is often the first thing people think of. It involves answering questions, guiding users to resources, and helping them develop research strategies. It can be in-person, over the phone, or via chat/email.
• Access Services: This covers everything related to getting actual materials, like lending books, interlibrary loan (borrowing from other libraries), and managing electronic resource access.
• Instructional Services: Teaching users how to find and evaluate information. This includes workshops on database searching, citation management, or even digital literacy skills.
• Outreach and Engagement: Proactively connecting with the community to understand their needs and promote services. This might involve events, partnerships, or special programs.
• Current Awareness Services (CAS) / Selective Dissemination of Information (SDI): Keeping users updated on new information in their specific areas of interest, often through alerts or newsletters.

User Studies

Photo by Walls.io on Pexels

User studies are the systematic process of investigating how users interact with information, services, and systems. The goal is to gather insights that can inform design, development, and improvement. Without user studies, services are often designed based on assumptions, which can lead to ineffective or underutilized resources.

Key Methods in User Studies

You have a toolkit of methods to understand your users:

• Surveys: Great for gathering quantitative data from a large group. You can ask about satisfaction, frequency of use, or perceived needs.
• Interviews: Offer qualitative, in-depth insights. You can ask "why" questions and explore complex user experiences individually.
• Focus Groups: Similar to interviews but involve a small group discussion, which can reveal shared perspectives and stimulate new ideas.
• Observation: Watching users interact with services or systems in their natural environment. This can reveal behaviors users might not articulate in surveys or interviews. (e.g., how they search a database, where they get stuck).
• Usability Testing: Directly observing users performing specific tasks with a system or interface (like a library website) to identify difficulties and areas for improvement.
• Log Analysis: Examining data from system logs (e.g., website traffic, database search queries) to understand actual usage patterns.

The Cycle of Service Improvement

Photo by MART PRODUCTION on Pexels

Understanding how information services and user studies fit together is crucial. It's a continuous cycle:

graph TD
    A["Identify User Needs (User Studies)"] --> B["Design/Improve Services"]
    B --> C["Implement Services"]
    C --> D["Monitor/Evaluate Service Use (User Studies)"]
    D --> A

This diagram shows a continuous loop: you identify needs, design or improve services based on those needs, implement them, then monitor their use and evaluate their effectiveness, which then informs the next round of identifying needs. This iterative approach ensures your services remain relevant and valuable.

3. Worked Example

Imagine you manage an academic library and notice that students often struggle with finding peer-reviewed articles. You decide to conduct a user study to understand this better.

1. Objective: Understand student difficulties with finding peer-reviewed articles and identify potential service improvements.
2. Method: You choose a mix of methods:
   • Survey: Send a short survey to 500 students asking about their confidence levels, common challenges, and preferred learning methods for research skills.
   • Focus Group: Conduct two focus groups with 8-10 students each to dive deeper into their experiences, frustrations, and suggestions.
   • Observation/Usability Test: Invite 10 students to perform a task: "Find three peer-reviewed articles on climate change published in the last 5 years" while you observe their screen and thought process.
3. Findings:
   • Survey: 60% of students reported low confidence; many mentioned not knowing where to start or how to filter results effectively.
   • Focus Group: Students expressed confusion between popular articles and scholarly ones, and difficulty distinguishing databases like Google Scholar from specific library databases. They suggested more hands-on workshops.
   • Observation: You noticed many students started with Google, then got lost in the library's website, or used too broad search terms in databases. Some didn't know how to use the "peer-reviewed" filter.
4. Action (Service Improvement): Based on this, you decide to:
   • Create a new online tutorial specifically on "Identifying and Finding Peer-Reviewed Articles."
   • Run more frequent, interactive workshops focused on effective database searching and using filters.
   • Add clearer "Peer-Reviewed Article" quick-links and guides on the library's research help page.

This cycle of studying users, identifying issues, and implementing solutions is how you ensure services meet real needs.

4. Key Takeaways

• Information services are the direct offerings connecting users to information and support.
• User studies are the systematic investigation of user behaviors and needs to inform service design.
• The core of effective information service lies in understanding your users deeply.
• Employ various user study methods (surveys, interviews, observation) to get a comprehensive view.
• Always use insights from user studies to iteratively improve and refine your information services.

Common mistakes to avoid:
- Assuming you know what users need: Always validate assumptions with actual user data.
- Designing services in isolation: Involve potential users in the design process if possible.
- Collecting data without acting on it: User studies are useless if their findings don't lead to service improvements.
- Using only one user study method: Different methods reveal different types of insights; combine them for a fuller picture.

5. Now Try It

Think about a library or information service you use regularly (e.g., your university library, a public library, or even a news aggregation app). For that service:

1. Identify one specific service (e.g., the book borrowing system, the reference desk, the library website).
2. Propose two different user study methods you would use to evaluate its effectiveness or identify areas for improvement.
3. For each method, briefly explain what kind of insights you'd expect to gain.

Success looks like: You've chosen relevant methods for your chosen service and clearly articulated how each method would help you understand user experience or needs for that specific service.